Herdman Calls Up Rizky Eka, Indonesia Reaches 25: An Open Left Flank and a Depth Gamble
**Core answer**: John Herdman called up Rizky Eka Pratama, a PSM Makassar left winger, taking Indonesia's squad to 25 players ahead of the FIFA ASEAN Cup 2026. PSM media officer Sulaiman Abdul Karim confirmed the news to VIVA on 22 September 2026; PSSI has not announced any final cuts. **Key facts**: - Rizky Eka Pratama, PSM Makassar left winger, started all three opening Super League 2026/2027 matches. - He recorded one assist in a 3-3 draw and previously played AFF Cup 2026 games against Vietnam and Singapore. - Indonesia's squad grew from 23 to 25 players across four days, 18–22 September 2026. - Shayne Pattynama of Persija Jakarta was added on 20 September 2026; Singapore also registered 25 players. - PSSI has made no official statement on squad cuts; the player has already left Jakarta. **Source attribution**: VIVA (Indonesian sports outlet), 22 September 2026, citing PSM Makassar media officer Sulaiman Abdul Karim | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Related Q&A**: Q: Who confirmed Rizky Eka's call-up? A: Sulaiman Abdul Karim, PSM Makassar's media officer, speaking to VIVA on 22 September 2026. Q: Why did Indonesia's squad expand to 25? A: According to VIVA, head coach John Herdman aimed to deepen squad depth, mirroring Singapore's 25-man registration. Q: Has Rizky Eka played for the senior national team before? A: Yes, he was previously called up by Herdman at AFF Cup 2026 and featured against Vietnam and Singapore.
On an autumn afternoon in Lyon, scrolling through a VIVA news flash from Indonesia, I came across a name that even Indonesian fans may have missed: Rizky Eka Pratama. The left winger from PSM Makassar had left Jakarta to join the national team. The confirmation did not come from the Indonesian FA, but from Sulaiman Abdul Karim, PSM's media officer. Publication date: 22 September 2026.
That is the entire content. One name. One position. One flight. And a count: 23, then 24, then 25.
That count is what stopped me. Indonesia calling up an extra player happens in every football nation, in every tournament cycle. But the way it happened is what matters. On 18 September, the squad had 23 players. On 20 September, Shayne Pattynama, a Persija Jakarta defender, was added. On 22 September, Rizky Eka was added. Four days. Three adjustments. Two different lines. And not a single official federation statement about who would be cut.
John Herdman sits in the hot seat. The English-Canadian coach who took Canada Women to Olympic gold and then led Canada Men to the 2026 World Cup in Qatar. Now he runs Indonesia, and he is doing something I find familiar to the point of discomfort: he is not locking the squad, he is stretching it.
I have followed Southeast Asian football for nearly two decades, long enough to know that in this region, a 25-man list is never just a 25-man list. It is a statement. And that statement, read closely, is not about Rizky Eka. It is about Indonesia's left flank, a position Herdman has not settled for months.
People call me a contrarian. I call them the crowd.
Indonesia enters the 2026 cycle with the familiar paradox of Southeast Asian football: passion at the highest level in the region, structures still searching for a shape. The Super League 2026/2027 has just kicked off. PSM Makassar, one of the archipelago's most storied clubs, has played three rounds. Rizky Eka started all three.
That is the only form data journalism offers. Three starts. One assist in a 3-3 draw. No expected goals, no successful dribbles, no heat map. I am not writing this to praise a young player. I am writing it because how a federation and a foreign coach handle squad depth says more than any single metric.
Herdman arrived in Indonesia with an unusual profile. He is a builder, not a firefighter. In Canada he turned a cold-climate football nation into a team with identity: high pressing, quick transitions, faith in rotation. But Southeast Asia is not Canada. Here, the weather is the eleventh opponent, grass is a luxury good, and the domestic calendar is a maze no one can map.
Some will read the 25-man call-up as depth-building. Modern football runs on benches. A regional tournament played across two or three weeks at one match every two days will grind down any squad that relies on eleven names. Calling 25 players to pick 23, or to rotate when injuries strike, is the logic of a coach raised where sports science is taken seriously.
Others will read it as undisclosed risk prevention. A coach who keeps adding bodies close to the deadline is usually hiding something: an unresolved injury, a suspended player, a paperwork issue. Adding one defender (Pattynama) and one wide midfielder (Eka) on two different lines suggests Herdman's concern is not one position but both flanks.
There is another reading, the one I lean toward: he has not settled the left flank.
It sounds small. But for a national team that has lived on wide attacks, an open left flank is a systemic problem. At AFF Cup 2026, Rizky Eka played against Vietnam and Singapore. This is not his first call-up under Herdman. That means, in the coach's mind, Eka has long been on the list, but never settled enough to lock in or cut. He exists in the grey zone: good enough to cover, not heavy enough to start.
And when a coach keeps pulling players into that grey zone, it means he is asking himself a question he cannot answer. How does Indonesia's left flank play? A touchline run to cross, or an inverted cut inside? A ball carrier, or a runner? Herdman has not finished that picture, and every extra call-up redraws it from scratch.
Back in 2026, when Mbappé was 18 at Monaco and Neymar had just broken the world transfer record at 222 million euros, I wrote that the French teenager was worth more than the Brazilian. I was insulted. Weeks later PSG paid 180 million euros for Mbappé. The lesson I took was not that I was brilliant. The lesson was that in football, small signals often carry more information than big numbers. Naming a left winger on 22 September is not a big story. But the way it was done is a small signal worth reading.
I do not write to be loved, I write to be read.
Now consider the other side of the door. When a player leaves his club for the national team, one party bears the risk and the other captures the benefit. PSM Makassar loses a starting left winger in the first three rounds of its own domestic season. It receives no compensation under standard international football mechanisms. If Eka picks up an injury on national duty, even a hamstring strain, PSM pays and the national team banks the playing experience.
In Europe, that asymmetry is offset by player insurance and financial agreements between federations and clubs. In Southeast Asia, where clubs run on thin margins and survive by trading players, the asymmetry is far heavier. A club losing an appreciating young player at a crucial point of the season loses more than points. It may lose future transfer value if the player is injured in a tournament that gives it nothing.
Eka is young. He can assist, he has played at AFF Cup 2026, he has faced Vietnam and Singapore. He sits on the rising side of the age-value curve. For PSM he is an appreciating asset. For the national team he is a backup option. That mismatch is exactly where emerging football nations often shoot themselves in the foot without noticing.
And there is one more thing, small but worth pausing on. The report refers to something called the FIFA ASEAN Cup 2026. But in the same report, when it mentions the matches Eka played under Herdman, it calls it the AFF Cup 2026. Two names. The same 2026 window. This is not a triviality. It is a sign of sports journalism writing faster than it verifies.
I do not care that an Indonesian reporter got a tournament name wrong. I care that a national team, a federation, and a foreign coach are all operating inside such a blurred information frame. When the tournament's own name is unsettled, counting whether the squad has 23, 25 or 26 players loses its certainty. Everything drifts. And in that drift, Herdman does the most rational thing a foreigner can do: he calls up more than he needs, so he has nothing to regret.
Indonesian media stresses that Singapore also registered 25 players. I find that detail interesting in a different way. It is expectation anchoring. When you write "Singapore also has 25," you are pre-empting your readers: do not ask why we called up so many, others are doing the same. The writer is countering a likely reader objection, not merely reporting. That is the moment news becomes communication, and communication always has intent.
Now, the doubt.
I may be completely wrong. Perhaps Herdman genuinely believes Eka deserves it, and this is just an ordinary addition to a list that will settle at some number both the federation and the press understand implicitly. Perhaps 25 is provisional, three or four players will be cut at the deadline, and no one outside a few local outlets will care. Perhaps I am inflating a pebble into a boulder, the way I once ignored that the 2026 final had five goals when I blurted out that France-Croatia 2026 was the highest-scoring final ever.
I know that feeling. Standing among 78,011 fans in Moscow, my head on fire, my mouth moving before my brain checked. So I set limits on myself. Perhaps the Eka call-up is purely administrative. Perhaps there is no story here, and I am a man hunting meaning in dust.
But I have been wrong before, and I have corrected myself publicly. In 2026 I declared that football without fans was a cheap fake. That May, the Bundesliga returned, I watched Dortmund play Schalke in an empty stadium, and players threw themselves at each other as if 80,000 were roaring. I was wrong. I retracted, and some readers left me for it. That is a price I accept. A stadium without spectators is just a parking lot painted the colour of grass.
This time, though, I do not think I am wrong on the main point. It is this: when a coach does not publish his cut plan, and the only spokesperson is a club media officer, you are looking at an information vacuum. And information vacuums in football are never neutral. They get filled with speculation, and speculation always raises pressure on the coach.
What I do believe is this. PSSI is silent. Herdman adds players. PSM loses one. Indonesian media uses an inconsistent tournament name. These four signals do not have to prove each other, but they point the same way: the system is running on inertia, not on a published plan.
And that is why a PSM left winger deserves a few thousand words.
The crowd believes in the spreadsheet. I believe in the pain on the pitch.
The spreadsheet here is "25". A neat, round, memorable number that fits a headline. What is not neat is the question nobody answers: among those 25, who will not be registered for the official matchday squad, who will sit in the stands in the opening game, and who will return to his club with a torn hamstring after playing every two days in Southeast Asian heat?
I have followed this region's football long enough to know that teams here mostly beat each other not by being better, but by making fewer mistakes in tired matches. Squad depth does not win you a game if nobody directs how it rotates. A left flank with three options but no attacking pattern is as meaningless as a left flank with one option that has been read.
At AFF Cup 2026, Eka faced Vietnam and Singapore. Those were two matches in which Herdman could observe him under real pressure. If, after those two games, he still has not settled, then one of two things is true: either Eka has not convinced him, or Herdman does not yet know what he wants from the position. Both possibilities are more worrying than a 25-man list.
And I ask myself: if a player who started his club's first three league games, played an AFF Cup, and faced the region's two biggest rivals is still only a backup, then who starts? The answer may be a name I have not heard. It may also be that there is no answer, and Herdman is waiting for the tournament to answer for him.
That is a way of working I do not like, but I understand why it exists. In an environment of dense domestic calendars, unstable pitches, and clubs unwilling to release players early, a foreign coach tends to call up many and settle late. It is safer for risk management. It is also more expensive in coaching time, because every new body means teaching the system again from scratch.
Football is a sport of habits. Players perform best when they know where the man beside them will run without looking. Building that understanding takes time. And time is the one thing you cannot call up.
So what I want to watch is not whether Eka scores. That would be ordinary. What I want to watch is whether Herdman, after all these additions, keeps a stable attacking spine through the tournament. If he rotates the left flank three straight games with three different players, the problem is not the players. The problem is the bench.
I have watched many Southeast Asian national teams win the group and collapse in the semi-final for exactly that reason. They have too many equivalent options, and because no one stands out, no one is fully trusted, so the lineup spins like a top until it meets an opponent with a clear spine and a clear idea. Then depth becomes a disadvantage. Too many options means no option.
I do not know whether Herdman will fall into that trap. But I know the signs. And the signs are right in front of us: a list patched repeatedly, a federation saying nothing, a club speaking instead, and a tournament whose own name the reporter gets wrong.
Here is where I state my view on modern football plainly.
Possession percentage is the most deceptive metric humans have ever invented to comfort themselves. A team with 60% possession built on meaningless sideways passes will lose to a team with 40% that knows what it wants. In the same way, a team with 25 players but no clear attacking idea will lose to a team with 23 where everyone knows his role.
Data people will tell you that conversion rate, key passes, and touches in the box are what to trust. I once believed that. I hold a statistics degree, and I spent years reading tables. Then I realized something simple: data arrives after the event. It describes what happened, it does not predict what comes next. To predict, you must look at people.
I was in Moscow in 2026 and Doha in 2026. I was inside Lusail on the night Argentina beat France on penalties, and while the world celebrated Messi, I wrote that Mbappé was the future. I shouted "90,000 people" in my piece when the real figure was 88,966. I forgot to check because I was drunk on the atmosphere. But my read on Mbappé was right, and it did not come from a spreadsheet. It came from watching a 23-year-old play as if he had nothing to fear.
A decade ago I believed in data. Now I believe in my eyes.
And my eyes, looking at Rizky Eka, see a player placed in football's most unstable position: good enough to be called, not yet good enough to be locked in. That is not the position of a winner. It is the position of a strategic reserve, a backdrop for a plan not yet formed.
Of course, I may again be the stubborn contrarian. Perhaps in a few months Rizky Eka starts a regional final, creates a goal, and all these lines become the noise of a foreigner in Lyon guessing about a country half a world away. I accept that risk. I was wrong about football without fans, and I apologized publicly. I am not afraid of being wrong. I am afraid of silence.
What I want from PSSI is not a grand statement. Just one sentence: of these 25, how many will be registered for the official squad, and when is the final list. That sentence would kill speculation, ease pressure on Herdman, and tell players like Eka where they stand. Silence, by contrast, pushes everyone into the grey zone.
And in football, the grey zone is where young players get left behind.
I am not writing this to defend or attack a name. I am writing it because the way we tell football stories usually skips the hardest part: structure. We love telling tales of diving headers, long-range strikes, tears. We rarely tell of the eleven PM phone calls between a club official and a federation official. But modern football is decided in those calls.
I once said I stand between two worlds, one dying and one refusing to be born. The Rizky Eka call-up sits exactly on that fault line. On one side is a football that tells stories through lists, legends, and nights that shake stadiums. On the other is a football that runs on squad data, insurance contracts, and muscle recovery indices. Eka belongs to both. He is a small legend of a club, and a variable in a foreign coach's spreadsheet.
When the whole world speaks in unison, my ears start ringing with the echo of error. Here, the world is not in unison. Indonesian media treat this as a formality. No one objects, no one debates. That is precisely when to pause.
So what do I predict?
I predict PSSI will announce the final list roughly seven to ten days before the opening match, and at least three players will be cut. I predict Rizky Eka will survive, not because he is superior, but because he has match experience against Vietnam and Singapore under Herdman, and because a coach about to play a short tournament tends to pick familiar names. I predict he will come off the bench in at least two group games. And I predict PSM Makassar will start slowly in the Super League without their starting left winger, and will receive nothing in return.
If PSM start losing while Eka sits on the bench for the national team, then the real story of this cycle has already surfaced: not how strong Indonesia is, but who pays for the regional dream.
And that is when the spreadsheet lies again. It will record that Indonesia has 25 players. It will not record what PSM has lost.
